Catastrophe's latest activity

  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    CMBR (r = radiation) is radiation (light and associated radiation) which has traveled from: "Light is made up of different...
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    Then whilst the CMB might be static (does anyone know?) the photons are still arriving i.e., light or consequent associated radiation...
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    The source (CMB) may be static, but the radiation (CMBR) certainly is not. Thus the radiation we see from the CMB is dynamic. If we...
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    I actually took out the patents in my name but did assign them. I used to visit RB (also when just R) but not in the last 35-40 years...
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    Yes. I agree. But who knows what the source is? Not a singularity. Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    Gibsense, why are you ignoring my post #57? https://forums.space.com/threads/argument-by-analogy.68326/page-3 Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    That is only one example. Are you suggesting "one therefore all"? I hope not. Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    I have no idea of the relevance? Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    Think what CMBR stands for. Is R = radiation? Is radiation static? Not in my opinion (knowledge). Where did I ever say radiation...
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    Google gives: Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    So the answer is dynamic. Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    So how would you describe CMBR ? static, dynamic or what? Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    This is playing with semantics. Are they, then, half moving and/or half static? Cat :)
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    A background of (light) radiation consists of a succession of photons, not frozen photons, which would be static. In principle, it is...
  • Catastrophe
    Catastrophe replied to the thread Argument by analogy.
    See my post #57: Google "Can a background move?" Cat :)