Recent content by DanIAm

  1. D

    Question Do We Really Need 6,000 Satellites?

    While the question, "do we really need 6000" satellites depends upon who you ask. I think everyone would agree that there is too much debris up there - and fie on those who made it, by blowing up satellites. As for all the dead satellites, boosters etc parked up there, leaving it parked given...
  2. D

    Question Do We Really Need 6,000 Satellites?

    6000 in LEO is not many. There is a lot of space in space, e.g. the circumference of the equator is 25,000 miles/40,000km and Starlink obviously doesn't travel only around the equator but spreads across the globe - Starlink is in 24 orbital planes, so 6000 satellites in 24 planes is 250...
  3. D

    Mars?

    "All of this needs to be tested, verified, retested and reverified several times over before any human astronaut straps down in a ship heading towards Mars." Those caveats means China will get there first and by a long margin, as risk will be viewed differently by them for the national good...
  4. D

    NASA Mars Missions

    They're a government agency and their fundamental mission is determined (and funded) by the government, so they don't get to change their focus. They are Aeronautics & Space, so, not Mars specifically, if you want your tax spending changed, lobby the politicians. The Aeronautics department...
  5. D

    NASA Needs To Think Bigger

    I'm Australian, NASA isn't part of my tax bill. So, I guess, none of my business... I get that space was so expensive, so exploration and science were government funded, it needed the likes of NASA to do the moon missions etc. Stay in the policy space for the regulation of space activities...
  6. D

    Is there a middle point between saving the environment and developing space travel further?

    I don't think it is so straightforward. The OP discussed repercussions on the environment, pollution isn't only about the launch fuel, it's in the whole chain of manufacturing rockets and satellites, the facilities, what happens to it after launch etc. Examples of factors at play. We just let...
  7. D

    Do foreign astronauts pay the US for rides to and from the Space station?

    You could ask NASA. https://science.nasa.gov/about-us/contact-us
  8. D

    Do foreign astronauts pay the US for rides to and from the Space station?

    Are they a foreign national that is a NASA employee and sent as part of their job? If so, then absolutely NASA is paying. As for the employees of other space agencies, speculation on my behalf here, a quick googling of NASA documents didn't reveal anything. But I would not think that NASA is...
  9. D

    Question What's your favorite SpaceX project?

    The promise of what Starship can be is mind blowing for launching cargo and people. If they can't stick landings and end up only as expendable rockets, it will still be a large capacity and very cheap rocket that opens up myriads of possibilities. But if they can nail the landings and...
  10. D

    Is there a middle point between saving the environment and developing space travel further?

    There are a lot of positives to the environment from the space industry. Yes it is polluting to make a satellite and put it into space, it needs mines, fuel, manufacturing, transport etc. But loads of our tangible measuring on the environment is done by satellites. A lot of the reporting on...
  11. D

    SpaceX Lies

    Kassini, you make a poignant observation in that SpaceX aren't exactly doing anything new, though they will have plenty of smaller innovations of their own. What seems to be the key to them that sets them apart, is getting it to work in production models at scaled cost, instead of the usual...
  12. D

    Question What will the NASA choice for the SpaceX Starship alone for Artemis Program lunar lander mean for the Space Launch System?

    On your metric (failure to land), you've banned almost the entirety of the history of spaceflight. Apologies to everyone if I get the details wrong, I ain't a rocket scientist. The useful comparison is against the rockets in the same class, e.g. the Delta IV or SLS from the States, Long...
  13. D

    Question What will the NASA choice for the SpaceX Starship alone for Artemis Program lunar lander mean for the Space Launch System?

    Here it is being moved from the pad 3 weeks after it successfully launched, it was a bit more successful than you think. View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlp4AFj9_no&t=25s
  14. D

    Mars Colonies are a Fantasy

    SpaceX has it's whole purpose as getting man to Mars, rocketry and satellites are the paving stones towards that. If he wanted to just get richer but do it in space, making factories, space stations and asteroid mining (with huge deposits of gold, platinum, rare earths etc) would be the prime...
  15. D

    SpaceX Lies

    This is a space forum and this is unrelated to space...