• Happy holidays, explorers! Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the Space.com community!

Was 2024 the year we finally started to understand dark energy?

Feb 7, 2024
5
2
15
Visit site
Well... Maybe. The Timescape paper is certainly the largest advancement in "dark energy" research we've had since the whole idea was introduced. And for those that are living in the dark, the Timescape paper, simplified, says that the calculations that led people to dark energy were made in error. There is no dark energy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: contrarian
Nov 20, 2024
23
0
10
Visit site
There is no dark energy.
It certainly seems questionable.

But then you read about changes : "That means it is dynamic and changing."

If the expansion rate is changing, there must be some dynamic explanation, it would seem. Could it be related to mass of the universe - perhaps something about its total mass, or something about gravity that is unknown to us?

Who else is contrarian on this one?
 
"Changing dark energy" is just one more leap down the rabbit hole of adding unexplained forces and materials to make the theory calculations match the observations where the known physics do not provide any way to make a match.

Science does have a history of making advances in knowledge by observing such mismatches and using them to look into something more closely, leading to the discovery of "new" physical laws. Special Relativity is a prime example of a successful theory that resulted that way.

On the other hand, when the same theory has come to the point that it is dependent on 20 times more mass and energy than we can detect or explain, and we still need to add the assumption that the unknown energy behaves in different manners at different times, science also has a history of that being a serious red flag that the theory is not correct.

So, I do applaud the theorists who are trying to think outside of "the box" that the Lambda-Cold-Dark-Matter model of cosmology has become.
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts