Black holes may obey the laws of physics after all, new theory suggests

[Admin]

A new recipe for black holes could do away with central singularities, saving the laws of physics from troubling infinities.

Black holes may obey the laws of physics after all, new theory suggests : Read more

 

[Unclear Engineer]

These stories about black holes always strike me as inconsistent with stories about the BBT "beginning" of our universe.

The whole picture would make a lot more sense if the material inside a black hole does not really get compressed to a zero dimension, and the universe oscillates density instead of having originated at a single point and "inflated" from there.

The theorists try to get away from talking about singularities in the BBT by saying that they don't know what happens below the Planck size for the whole universe. So, why can't the same theorists simply say that they don't know what happens below the Planck size for the mass in a black hole? Shouldn't that make them equally "happy" or "unhappy" in both cases?

Frankly, it makes me unhappy in both cases.

But, because we do not know what matter does in such extremely dense conditions, we really don't have a way to "show" that matter reached a point of infinite density in either case. We simply cannot observe what it does. We only have the extrapolations by sub-atomic particle physicists, using their theories. Which they will only admit break down at Planck size.

But, why not consider that they might break down at much less dense conditions?

Another area of comment is the often stated hope that we will someday learn about the insides of black holes from observations of gravity waves. But, just like light, our theories say that gravity waves will not propagate faster than light propagates. So, no information should be coming out of black holes via gravity waves, either.

Actually, if the mass that goes into a black hole actually "leaves" via a white hole "somewhere else", I don't think current theory would let us know that, either. The information of its departure should still not make it past the inside of the event horizon, right?

 

[B.E. Dumbings]

A new recipe for black holes could do away with central singularities, saving the laws of physics from troubling infinities.

Black holes may obey the laws of physics after all, new theory suggests : Read more

I would believe that black holes can alter or change surroundings due to what stage they are in and size and energy levels contained within them and what changes occur from them. Do they have extra long affects or just pull. What is aligned in space with them and do they have synergistic affects with other celestial bodies and phenomena around. I would suggest that maybe the laws of physics can be altered/changed for while with incredible amounts of energies and emissions occur from these black holes, quarks, quasars and other natural phenomena and maybe even counterparts in the known universe with similar properties. If studied from different vantage points, one or more be able to understand and grasp and expand knowledge of these phenomena. The laws of physics and natural forms of compounds and chemicals/elements can and are probably altered due to different forms of energy compressed, altered, released thus changing the nature of their form/forms depending on flow and form. We have similar large devices that can emulate/simulate such processes, but are mere experiments, controlled due to proximity and dangers associated with emissions,releases. Larger is better!