<blockquote><font class="small">In reply to:</font><hr /><p>whole point seems to be that basis of life could start out in the cold space in matterial that was still waiting to coalesce into stars and then after they were born it would seed them and their planets and where conditions permited, the life as we know it here on Earth had risen<br />vanDivX<p><hr /></p></p></blockquote><br /><br /><blockquote><font class="small">In reply to:</font><hr /><p>here is NOT seeding going on. It's simply continuing impacts of masses from the disc around then sun when it was forming. That's NOT seeding, it's simply continuing to grow by my meteor impacts.<br /><br />it already HAS, the C, S, H20, CH4, and the complex organics from the past several 100 megayears which led to its formation. Adding more carbonaceious meteorites to that planet is not going to change it much because its been collecting those for megayears!! There is NO seeding going on. Collection of these meteors/asteroids simply continues. <br /> ... <br />To call this seeding, would be like adding a tsp. of gravel to a gravel collection which is already Kms. in size.<br />Seeding refers ONLY to adding a critical piece of biological matter form which life can start.<br /><br />But it's been there already for mega years!! HOw can that be seeding?<p><hr /></p></p></blockquote><br /><br />ok, I hear you but my take on this was that Earth in early stages was way too hot before crust formed and for some time after that for any life to exist here, ditto for the Sun except that one never cooled off but on the contrary<br /><br />now seeds are seeds but if you are throwing them into lighted furnace or hot early Earth you are not seeding but simply adding matter, you are only seeding if you throw them on the ground that is ready for them to start developing, therefore even if all the time the same material kept accumulating to make up the Earth, only when it cooled enough could it be called seeding (although real seeding came still much later, it is not enough <div class="Discussion_UserSignature"> </div>