Jupiter used to be twice as big as it is now — it could have held 2,000 Earths

[Admin]

A new study reveals early Jupiter was twice its current size with a magnetic field 50 times stronger.

Jupiter used to be twice as big as it is now — it could have held 2,000 Earths : Read more

 

[Catastrophe]

A new study reveals early Jupiter was twice its current size with a magnetic field 50 times stronger.

Jupiter used to be twice as big as it is now — it could have held 2,000 Earths : Read more

Ambiguous headline.

Big, as in volume? big as in mass? big as in density?

Including atmosphere? What is atmosphere?

Cat

 

[newtons_laws]

From the article: "The team's calculations indicate that young Jupiter had a radius nearly twice its current size, with a volume large enough to hold more than 2,000 Earths. In the present day, the planet's volume can fit 1,321 Earths"

There's a glaring arithmetical error here. If as stated the radius was nearly twice its current size then since the volume of a sphere goes as the cube of the radius if the radius was double the volume would be 8 times greater! The quote about being large enough to hold more than 2,000 Earths rather than the present day 1,321 Earths suggest that the writer meant to say that the volume was almost twice its current size, not the radius!!

 

[NicolasDf]

A new study reveals early Jupiter was twice its current size with a magnetic field 50 times stronger.

Jupiter used to be twice as big as it is now — it could have held 2,000 Earths : Read more

I would like to offer my view on this. Jupiter has the maximum mass our Solar System can support. I’ve also written a paper on this and the math works unviversally. The mass and speed contraints that I propose can be extrapolated for any system or moon.
Anybody interested in this approach can read my paper on Zenodo: https://zenodo.org/records/15518692

Thanks, DN