Big Bang as a Startup Sequence
Additional Insights from the CMB Using Modified Recombination Models
Extended or Delayed Recombination and a Thicker Last-Scattering Surface
Impact on the Visibility Function:
In the UMT scenario, if the cyclic energy (E_cyc) is below the threshold (E_threshold) needed for rapid atomic binding, the effective recombination rate is reduced. This means the free electron fraction, x_e, decreases more slowly, leading to a broader (thicker) surface of last scattering.
Visibility function:
g(z) = [dτ/dz] · exp[-τ(z)]
Here, an extended recombination period (a larger τ or a broader g(z)) would smear out or slightly damp the sharpness of the acoustic peaks in the CMB temperature power spectrum.
Modifications in Acoustic Peak Structures
Peak Positions and Damping Tail:
The acoustic peaks in the CMB are due to oscillations in the photon-baryon plasma. A modified recombination history shifts the "freeze-out" of these oscillations.
Observable effect:
- The positions of the acoustic peaks could shift. - The amplitude of the damping tail (the falloff at smaller angular scales) may be altered.
By comparing these details with high-resolution measurements (e.g., from Planck), one could check for consistency with UMT predictions.
Polarization Signatures
Enhanced Thomson Scattering:
A delayed recombination phase means free electrons persist for a longer time, increasing the amount of Thomson scattering. This modifies the polarization (E-mode) pattern of the CMB.
Observable effect:
- The amplitude and possibly the angular distribution of polarization anisotropies would be affected, offering another signature that can be cross-checked against the temperature data.
Potential Spectral Distortions
Departure from a Perfect Blackbody:
In the standard model, recombination happens quickly enough that the CMB spectrum remains almost a perfect blackbody. However, an extended recombination phase might allow residual free electrons to introduce minor distortions.
Possible distortions include:
- µ-distortions or y-distortions, which are small deviations from the blackbody spectrum.
Detecting even slight spectral distortions would support the idea that the recombination process was modified by insufficient cyclic energy.
Constraining UMT Parameters
The modified recombination model introduces parameters (such as the ratio E_cyc/E_threshold and a sensitivity exponent n in the modulation factor f_cyc) that affect the recombination rate:
R'_rec = f_cyc · R_rec
where f_cyc = min[1, (E_cyc/E_threshold)^n]
By measuring the optical depth τ(z), the width of the last-scattering surface g(z), and the detailed shapes of the temperature and polarization power spectra, these parameters can be statistically constrained.
Summary
In this UMT-based scenario, while sequence and time exist as usual, the early universe did not have sufficient cyclic (rotational) kinetic energy to trigger rapid atomic binding.
This leads to a prolonged or delayed recombination phase, which manifests in the CMB as:
A broader surface of last scattering.
Altered positions and amplitudes of the acoustic peaks.
Modified polarization signals from enhanced Thomson scattering.
Potential small spectral distortions.
Together, these features provide additional channels to test and constrain UMT’s predictions using precise CMB observations.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Modified Recombination Models in Universal Motion Theory (UMT
This section outlines a preliminary model of how UMT modifies the standard recombination process of the early universe. In conventional cosmology, recombination occurs as free electrons combine with protons to form neutral hydrogen when the universe cools sufficiently. Under UMT, the cyclic, closed motion—central to the framework—is insufficiently vigorous during the "startup" phase, delaying or modifying the onset of stable atomic formation.
Standard Recombination Background
The standard recombination process is commonly modeled using the Saha equation for equilibrium (or the Peebles equation for non-equilibrium effects). The evolution of the free electron fraction, \( x_e \), with time is approximately given by:
dx_e/dt = -R_{rec} \, x_e^2 + I_{ion} \, (1 - x_e)
where \( R_{rec} \) is the recombination rate and \( I_{ion} \) is the ionization rate.
The UMT Modification Concept
In the UMT “startup” scenario, the cyclic (or rotational) kinetic energy that is critical for robust atomic binding is below the necessary threshold. To incorporate this effect, we introduce a modulating factor, \( f_{cyc} \), which scales the effective recombination rate. We define a modified recombination rate as:
R'_{rec} = f_{cyc} \cdot R_{rec}
Here, \( f_{cyc} \) depends on the ratio of the cyclic energy intensity \( E_{cyc} \) to a threshold value \( E_{threshold} \) required for stable atomic binding. A simple functional form is proposed as:
f_{cyc} = \min\Biggl( 1, \Bigl(\frac{E_{cyc}}{E_{threshold}}\Bigr)^n \Biggr)
where \( n \) is a sensitivity parameter controlling how quickly \( f_{cyc} \) approaches unity as \( E_{cyc} \) increases. When \( E_{cyc} < E_{threshold} \), \( f_{cyc} < 1 \), thus reducing the effective recombination rate and delaying the formation of neutral atoms.
Modified Ionization History
With this modification, the evolution of the free electron fraction becomes:
dx_e/dt = -f_{cyc} \, R_{rec} \, x_e^2 + I_{ion} \, (1 - x_e)
This altered ionization history impacts the optical depth \( \tau(z) \) for Thomson scattering and, consequently, the visibility function \( g(z) \) defined as:
g(z) = \frac{d\tau}{dz} \, \exp\bigl(-\tau(z)\bigr)
A delayed or extended recombination period results in a broader \( g(z) \), which may dampen the acoustic peaks in the CMB power spectrum and alter the observed polarization patterns.
Implications for Observations
Under this UMT modification:
- The recombination epoch may shift to a lower redshift and be drawn out over a longer interval, creating a “thick” surface of last scattering.
- The damping of the acoustic oscillations in the CMB may be enhanced, leading to modifications in the heights and positions of the temperature anisotropy peaks.
- Enhanced Thomson scattering during the prolonged ionized phase could imprint subtle differences on the CMB polarization (specifically in the E-modes).
Next Steps
To test this modified recombination scenario, the following steps are proposed:
- Refine the functional form of \( f_{cyc} \) based on theoretical estimates of \( E_{cyc} \) derived from UMT dynamics.
- Implement the modified recombination equations in a numerical cosmological code to simulate the evolution of \( x_e \), \( \tau(z) \), and \( g(z) \).
- Compare the simulated CMB power spectra (both temperature and polarization) with observational data (e.g., from Planck) to constrain the parameters \( E_{threshold} \) and \( n \).
This approach would help determine whether the UMT “startup” scenario—where insufficient cyclic energy delays atomic binding—provides a viable alternative to the standard recombination model in explaining observed features of the CMB.
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram